The magazine is not on sale yet up here in Alaska but it is down south. Several of the media types are commenting on the article of Levi Johnson talking about Sarah Palin and her family. For the first time it almost sounds like they could tolerate her. Here is the article from the Anchorage Daily News
Johnston: Creep or bearer of insight about Palin?
UPDATE: NPR's "All Things Considered" descended into the seedy underworld of celebrity journalism tonight and called Brendan Joel Kelley of the Anchorage Press to get the local take on the ongoing Levi Johnston media crusade.
The major-media pundits on the coasts have now had time to digest all of Levi Johnston's observations in Vanity Fair about the Palin household (the magazine won't go on sale on Alaska newsstands until Tuesday). Frequent Sarah Palin critics Ruth Marcus of The Washington Post and Gail Collins of The New York Times are among those harsh on Johnston. (Continued after jump)
(If you can't wait for VF's October edition to go on sale here, read the humorously "simplified" version posted by The Awl.)
Marcus calls him an "opportunistic creep" and writes, "Only in America can this be a springboard to a modeling and acting career." Regardless of the accuracy of his observations, she says, it's unfair to lay them out in Vanity Fair. "Would anybody's household look especially attractive if its inner workings were splashed on the pages of Vanity Fair by someone with every motive to accentuate the negative? I know mine wouldn't. ... Sarah Palin didn't deserve to be vice president -- but she didn't deserve this either."
"For the first time in my life, I feel sympathy for Sarah Palin," adds Collins. "Given the fact that Johnston is a 19-year-old high school dropout whose mother was arrested last year on six felony drug counts, it is conceivable that he is not the perfect arbiter of normal families. But even if he were an Eagle Scout with a scholarship to Harvard, can you imagine anything worse than discovering your daughter's teenage ex-boyfriend has been given a national platform to discuss his impressions of her mom's parenting skills?"
But Collins, like others, was intrigued by at least some of Johnston's observations. "I was fascinated by his claim that [Palin] doesn't know how to shoot a gun. Hunting is one of the very few matters in which Levi Johnston seems like a trustworthy source, and if he says she showed no familiarity with weapons, I want to know more. In fact, I think Palin should never be allowed to bring that moose stuff up again until she appears at a rifle range and gives us a demonstration."
Likewise, Robin Abcarian of the Los Angeles Times advises taking Johnston with a grain of salt, but ... "Still, he did live with Alaska's first family and was privy to deeply private incidents and attitudes. And the details of what went on inside this apparently dysfunctional American family are juicy."
Alex Koppelman of Salon.com agrees some of what Johnston says he saw in the Palin household is "not uncommon in a family where two parents are working, especially where one of them has a high-profile, high-stress job like, say, governor." But he's still not convinced Palin is a totally innocent victim of a vindictive almost-son-in-law. "It does tend to put a little bit of a crimp in Palin's family values talk."
Brian Moylan at Gawker says Palin needs Johnston to keep her profile high among core fans: "How harmful is Levi? He's only riding Sarah Palin's coattails - VF gave her top billing - thus keeping her in the spotlight." And anyway, he says, the GOP and Palin brought this on themselves by trying to exploit Johnston during the presidential campaign: "Yes, Levi is shamelessly cashing in on his brief moment in the sun, but if it weren't for the GOP and their collective delusion about the realities of teenage life, he never would have had a platform to begin with." Robert Schlesinger of U.S. News and World Report jokingly speculates that "Johnston is a double-agent, a mole dispatched by Sarah Palin to stem her declining poll numbers and generate sympathy in the so-called mainstream media."
Cynthia Tucker of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution agrees that Palin bears the greatest blame, but also advises Johnston to shut up and questions his intelligence: "Levi is old enough to take responsibility for his own actions. He may not yet be old enough to drink, but he is old enough to legally marry, sign a contract and join the military. He ought to have sense enough to know that he is doing nothing but harming his chances to have a role in the life of his baby boy. If the Palins won't let him see the baby now, how does he think they'll respond to his continuing tattle-tale interviews?"
My Butt Jiggle Is Just My Little Way of Waving Good-Bye. -- Maxineism